Leaf · a use of が (ga)
が Question word and its answer
Pattern
誰が来ますか
N4 6 examples
When a question word like {誰|だれ}, {何|なに} or どれ is the subject of a sentence, it always takes が, never は.
The answer that fills in the question word takes が too: 「{誰|だれ}が{来|き}ますか」「{田中|たなか}さんが{来|き}ます」.
Learners often answer with は out of habit. But は marks something already known, and here the answer is the new piece of information.
Tip: if the question has が after the question word, put が after your answer as well.
が or は?は sets up a topic you already know about and then says something about it, so a question word can never take は; が points at the one unknown, so {誰|だれ}が asks the question and {田中|たなか}さんが answers it. Compare: は for topic "as for"
例文 · 6 examples
Tap a word for its meaning; words with a link are in the tree.